United nations framework convention on climate change unfccc. What is the kyoto protocol problem failure or success. The effects on developing countries of the kyoto protocol and. Convention on climate change that has so far been ratifi ed by 192 countries. The list of industrialized countries and economies in transition that have their greenhouse gas emissions capped under the kyoto protocol as listed in annex b. Introduction the dynamics of climate change negotiations has recently received new impulses. Evaluating developed countries historical climate debt to developing countries submission by the republic of bolivia to the awglca introduction in the context of paragraph 1 b i of the bali action plan, we call on developed countries, including countries that are not parties to the kyoto protocol, to commit to deep emission. It was agreed on 11 december 1997 at the 3rd conference of the parties to the treaty when they met in kyoto, and entered into force on 16 february 2005 as of november 2007, 174 parties have ratified the protocol. Nov 18, 2010 in this paper, we investigate the impact of the kyoto protocol on world emissions of a greenhouse gas, carbon dioxide. Group 6ankita mahajan 110 briji komban 115 ramya uk 144 2. Delegates present at the conference agreed to a pact to collectively reduce the amount of greenhouse gases emitted by developed countries by 5.
In this period 37 countries annex 1 party committed to reduce ghg levels by 18% below the level of 1990. We use a large unbalanced panel data consisting of 177 countries from 1980 to 2006. The kyoto protocol, once entered into force, would create a market where annex i parties with commitments listed in annex b of the protocol could acquire and. Annex b countries have their reduction targets formally stated. Australia, the european union and its 28 member states, belarus, iceland, kazakhstan, liechtenstein, norway, switzerland, and ukraine. The maximum amount of emissions measured as the equivalent in carbon dioxide that a party may emit over a commitment period in order to comply with its emissions target is known as a partys assigned amount. The eus 8% target only refers to the current 15 member states, and this will not change after enlargement. First, there are no control countries for nonannex b countries to conduct panel data analysis by the stirpat model, since most developing countries have joined the kyoto protocol. The effects on developing countries of the kyoto protocol. Unfccc, kyoto protocol unfccc summit 1997, carbon trading. It involves mostly the developed countries and those in transition to a market economy, requiring the application of tax and regulatory measures as well as the. The unfccc, the first international measure to address the problem, was adopted in may 1992 and came into force in march 1994. Dark blue canada, which withdrew from the protocol in december 2011.
The kyoto protocol is a protocol to the united nations framework convention on climate change unfccc, aimed at fighting global warming the unfccc is an international environmental treaty with the goal of achieving the stabilization of greenhouse gas concentrations in the atmosphere at a level that would. The kyoto protocol to the united nations framework convention. Concluded at montreal on 16 sep tember 1987 authentic texts. Those parties that have not yet signed the kyoto protocol may accede to it at any time. Kyoto protocolpresented byjibin m varghesepr10ee1002justin babypr10ee1007shanthibhushan b pr10ee1025manu n govindpr10ee1028ajeesh gpr10ee1034. Similarly, annex b of the kyoto protocol, supra note 2, identifies bulgaria, croatia, the czech republic, estonia, hungary, latvia, lithuania, poland, romania, the russian federation, slovakia, slovenia and ukraine as countries that are undergoing the process of transition to a market economy. Expost assessment of the kyoto protocol quantification. As of february 2020, 7 states have accepted this amendment.
Annex b parties to the kyoto protocol that also adopted emissions reduction targets for 20082012. Parties to the kyoto protocol not listed in annex i of the convention the non annex i parties are mostly lowincome developing countries. In gtem, climate change policy analysis is based on a reference case scenario, which does not include current or planned policy responses to climate change, and policy scenarios that represent implementation of the. The kyoto protocol is an international agreement, which for the first time establishes legally binding limits for 37 industrialized countries on emissions of carbon dioxide and other greenhouse. Canada, japan, new zealand and russia that were part of the first commitment period opted out from the new commitments. Signatories to the protocol that have not ratified. Protocol at different stages of the negotiation process for major annex b country groups. Arabic, chinese, english, french, russian and spanish. In gtem, climate change policy analysis is based on a reference case scenario, which does not include current or planned policy responses to climate change, and policy scenarios that represent implementation of the kyoto protocol and developing countries 1. For example, most european countries are required to decrease their emissions by 8%. Proposal from kazakhstan to amend annex b to the kyoto protocol pdf. It is like committing only half of what one needs to commit. Kyoto protocol annex b party ca n earn emission reduct ion units in order to meet its ky oto target eru s, each eq uivalent t o one to nne of co 2 fro m an emissio nred uction.
The protocol establishes legally binding, mandatory emissions reductions for the six major greenhouse gases 1. The first is a set of 1 the list of parties to the convention in annex i differs only slightly from the annex b grouping developed in the kyoto protocol and used in this analysis. Goals were set for developed countries, listed in annex i of the unfccc and annex b of the kyoto protocol. The economic costs and ineffectiveness of the kyoto protocol. Annex ii parties refer to developed countries on the list of annex i parties. This kind of approach ignores long term social and economic costs. They are in non annex group and they have no binding obligations in the kyoto protocol to limit their co2 emissions. Kyoto protocol which was adopted on 11 december 1997 by the conference of the. The united nations framework convention on climate change unfccc and its kyoto protocol provide the only international framework for combating climate change 1. Each annex b country is obligated to develop a standardized national registry connected to the itl. Under kyoto protocol, annex 1 countries can meet their targets by cutting emissions or buying unused allowances carbon credits, carbon trading from other countries. The industrialized countries agreed to a target reduction in emissions from 1990 levels which vary from 6 to 8 percent with a handful of countries having less stringent targets. The second commitment period of the kyoto protocol is 8 year long. It is the first legally binding global agreement to cut greenhouse gases.
On december 11th, 1997 a final agreement on the kyoto protocol was achieved. The remaining annex b countries decided to continue the kyoto process and reached a compromise on the climate treaty at the resumed 6th conference of the parties to the unfccc cop6bis in bonn, july 2001 and a subsequent deal signed at cop7, the marrakech accords. It requires that annex i countri es listed again in annex b of the protocol reduce their aggregate greenhous e gas emissions by. Jun 06, 2016 kyoto protocol countries kyoto protocol countries are called parties of the protocol. Nonetheless, one often sees the phrase annex b countries. Apr 15, 2011 kyoto protocolpresented byjibin m varghesepr10ee1002justin babypr10ee1007shanthibhushan b pr10ee1025manu n govindpr10ee1028ajeesh gpr10ee1034. Developing countriesboth countries of the kyoto protocol. Indeed, a global market for rights to emit countries under the kyoto protocol and compare the carbon dioxide could reduce the cost of meeting the outcome with a world in which annex b countries meet kyoto targets by almost 90 percent, if the market were to. Parties to the kyoto protocol adopted an amendment to annex b to the kyoto protocol by decision 10cmp. We do, however, consider two sets of actions that annex b countries could take to limit negative impacts on nonannex b countries.
The protocol also defines legally binding obligations on each country to reduce their emissions by set amounts within a defined period of time. Ellerman, jacoby, and decaux examine the trading of caps assigned to annex b countries under the kyoto protocol and compare the outcome with a world in which annex b countries meet their kyoto targets without trading. The remaining annex b countries decided to continue the kyoto process and reached a compromise on the climate treaty at the resumed 6th conference of the parties to the unfccc cop6bis in bonn, july 2001 and a subsequent. The individual targets for annex i parties are listed in the kyoto protocol s annex b. Annex i and annex b countries parties are the signatory nations to the kyoto protocol that are subject to caps on their emissions of ghgs and committed to reduction targets countries with developed economies.
As of june 20, there are 192 parties to the kyoto protocol to the united nations framework convention on climate change, which aims to combat global warming. The group of countries listed in annex ii to the united nations framework convention on climate change unfccc. The kyoto protocol is a protocol to the international framework convention on climate change with the objective of reducing greenhouse gases that cause climate change. The subset of annex i parties that have accepted greenhouse gas ghg emission reduction targets for the period 20082012 under article 3 of the kyoto protocol. In this paper, we investigate the impact of the kyoto protocol on world emissions of a greenhouse gas, carbon dioxide. It comes into effect 90 days after it is ratified by 55 states, but the annex b countries that ratify must account for 55% of the co2 emitted by those countries in 1990. As the cdm concerns nonannex 1 countries, which in the kyoto protocol have no emission reduction targets, it poses some additional challenges related.
The united nations framework convention on climate change unfccc has annex i parties and annex ii parties. Currently, there are 192 parties 191 states and 1 regional economic integration organization to the kyoto treaty to the unfccc. Countries included in annex b to the kyoto protocol and their emissions targets country target 1990 20082012 eu15, bulgaria, czech republic. Indeed, a global market for rights to emit countries under the kyoto protocol and compare the carbon dioxide could reduce the cost of meeting the outcome with a world in which annex b countries meet kyoto. The kyoto protocol to the united nations framework. They have not yet made up their mind to sign the treaty as annexi countries and come within the ambit of the legal obligations to the co2 reductions. Kyoto protocol countries kyoto protocol countries are called parties of the protocol. A second commitment period was agreed in 2012, known as the doha amendment to the kyoto protocol, in which 37 countries have binding targets. As of june 20, there are 192 parties to the kyoto protocol to the united nations framework.
Expost assessment of the kyoto protocol quantification of. Kyoto protocol countries are groups of annex i, annex ii and non annexed parties of unfccc. The agreement requires these countries to consider ways to minimize adverse. Montreal protocol on substances that deplete the ozone layer with annex. Annex b of kyoto protocol to the united nations framework convention on climate change and. In 1997 the kyoto protocol, a binding ghg reduction plan, was adopted. Open for signature from 16 march 1998 to 15 march 1999 at united nations headquarters by that date the protocol had received 84 signatures. Annex i parties committed to legally binding targets to limit or reduce emissions of six major ghgs, with an aggregate goal of a 5 percent reduction from 1990 levels by 20082012. Conference of the parties to the unfccc in kyoto, japan, on 11 december 1997.
The economic costs and ineffectiveness of the kyoto protocol the demands of the kyoto protocol the kyoto protocol was adopted back in 1997 but came into effect only in february 2005. The kyoto protocol is a protocol to the united nations framework convention on climate change, an international environmental treaty with the goal of stabilisation of greenhouse gas concentrations in the atmosphere at a level that would prevent dangerous anthropogenic interference with the climate system. Countries included in annex b to the kyoto protocol and their emissions targets. Jacoby abstract under the kyoto protocol, the worlds wealthier countries assumed binding commitments to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. The emissions limitations of annex i parties varies between different parties. Under the trading scenario the former soviet union is the main seller of carbon dioxide. Annex b parties with binding targets in the first period but which withdrew from the protocol. Annex i refers to the countries identified for reduction in the united nations framework convention on climate change unfccc while the annex b is an adjusted list of the countries identified under the more recent kyoto protocol. The groups were made on the basis of the countries 1997 economic capacity to commit themselves and their industry. Kyoto protocol summary first international treaty on. Pdf explaining the variation in commitment to the kyoto protocol.
Annex b parties are the 45 countries that signed the kyoto protocol, i. After the us decided to withdraw from the kyoto protocol, the remaining annex b parties reached a compromise on the climate treaty at the resumed cop6 in bonn, july 2001. The effect of the kyoto protocol on carbon dioxide emissions. The kyoto protocol negotiations were completed in late 1997. India, china and brazil are considered to be the most advanced developing countries. May 22, 2002 annex b parties are the 45 countries that signed the kyoto protocol, i. The kyoto protocol and developing countries mustafa babiker, john m. As of february 1999, 76 countries have signed the protocol and. May 23, 2011 the establishment of commitments for the reduction of greenhouse gases that are legally binding for annex i countries is the most important point of kyoto protocol and the very heart of it.
In examining the effects of the kyoto protocol upon nonannex b parties, we assume that the. Permitted case 2 all annex b countries with the exception of the us all annex b countries beginning in 1st commitment period for annex b countries ratifying the kyoto protocol. Under the trading scenario the former soviet union is the main seller of carbon dioxide permits and japan. Second, the largest part of the mitigation effect from the kyoto protocol in annex b countries is. This total includes 191 states 189 united nations member states as well as the cook islands and niue and one supranational union the european union. Second, the largest part of the mitigation effect from the kyoto protocol in annex b countries is related to reductions in industrial gases. Developing countriesboth countries of the kyoto protocol and.
Annex 1 as well as a change in the distribution of the burden, see bollen and gielen 1997 for the macroeconomic consequences. The kyoto protocol was adopted in 1997 and it became law on february 16, 2005. Kyoto protocol is an agreement reached by government delegates at the 1997 united nations u. The kyoto protocol requires industrialized annex b countries to reduce co2 emissions by an average 5. Finally, part vi focuses on reforming the wto rules in order to accommodate trade measures used by the parties to the unfccc and the kyoto protocol in their implementation of their treaty commitments. B in the protocol these are listed as parties, not countries, and it will be seen that the european community is one of the parties. Annex ii parties are the 24 countries, plus the european union, listed in annex ii to the united nations framework convention on climate change unfccc, i. By default, the other countries are referred to as non annex i parties. With the protocols 20082012 commitment period expiring, the doha amendment to the kyoto protocol was agreed to, which establishes new commitments for the period 202020. The ten accession countries scheduled to join the eu in may 2004 all have ratified the kyoto protocol and have their own kyoto targets of between 6% and 8%. International concern about climate change has led to the kyoto protocol, negotiated in 1997. Kyoto protocol to the united nations framework convention on. Commitments for annex i parties under paragraph 1bi of.
These are annex i countries without the countries with economies in transition eit. Not permitted case 3 all annex b countries with the exception of the us all annex b countries beginning in 1st. The key finding of this paper is that there are structural breaks in the data that demonstrate the effects of the international agreement. Kyoto, a flexible protocol annex b countries signed and ratified annex b countries signed, ratification pending nonsignatories signed and ratified source.
1481 980 1560 979 541 449 396 1181 36 386 442 352 128 148 1325 168 1357 917 462 1268 624 1317 1530 264 847 1003 29 263 757 399 1617 850 1529 201 1505 948 913 1131 977 46 1191 1466 1103 195 965